The Subaru Forester is Subaru's midsize SUV, finding itself best suited for those familiar with cars like the Escape and Traverse from Ford and Chevy, differentiating itself from those popular entries in the class with its unique interior and more convenient cargo storage in the rear. In this used Subaru Forester buying guide, we'll be exploring the world of Forester reliability, building an AWD SUV checklist as we look into the world of used Subaru ownership costs.
Key Takeaways
- The Forester is known for standard all-wheel drive and excellent visibility.
- Buyers should inspect service history and verify oil changes were consistently performed.
- Practical cargo space and strong safety ratings enhance long-term ownership appeal.
Which Subaru Forester to stay away from?
When shopping for a used Subaru Forester, it's generally best to avoid the 2011-2015 model years, as well as older 1998-2001 examples. The 2011-2013 Foresters are known for excessive oil consumption related to the FB25 engine, while the 2014 and 2015 models combined those oil-burning issues with early continuously variable transmission (CVT) problems that, in some cases, resulted in costly transmission replacements.
First-generation models from the late 1990s and early 2000s are also well known for head gasket failures, making them riskier purchases unless documented repairs have already been completed. The 2019 Forester is generally more reliable mechanically but has received complaints about cracked windshields and failures of the Thermo Control Valve (TCV).
Buyers seeking a dependable used Forester should instead focus on 2016-2018 or 2021 and newer models, which benefited from improvements to the engine, piston rings, and CVT reliability. Older second-generation models (2003-2008) can also be good values if major maintenance, including timing belt and head gasket service, has already been performed. Regardless of model year, it's important to review service records, confirm that recommended maintenance has been completed, and have the vehicle inspected before purchase, particularly if it is equipped with a CVT.
Used Subaru Forester Buying Guide
| Feature |
Used Subaru Forester |
| Best For |
AWD daily driving |
| Standout Strength |
Visibility and safety |
| Engine |
2.5L Boxer |
| AWD |
Standard |
| Common Issues |
Oil consumption (older years), CVT maintenance |
| What to Inspect |
Oil change history, CVT service |
| Best Model Years |
2019-2023 |
| Ownership Costs |
Low |
What are the best and worst years for a Subaru Forester?
The best used years for the Subaru Forester are generally 2016-2018 and 2020-2024, offering the strongest balance of reliability, safety, and modern features. The 2016-2018 models represent the most refined years of the fourth generation, benefiting from improved CVT programming, available Subaru EyeSight driver-assistance technology, and fewer mechanical complaints than earlier models. For buyers seeking a newer Forester, the 2020-2024 models stand out with standard EyeSight safety features, excellent crash-test ratings, updated interiors, and a reputation for strong overall dependability while retaining user-friendly physical climate controls.
Some model years deserve extra caution. The 1998-2001 Foresters are well known for head gasket failures, while the 2006 and 2009-2010 models also experienced significant engine-related issues. The 2014 and 2015 Foresters are widely considered the least desirable years because of excessive oil consumption, early CVT transmission problems, and suspension complaints. Buyers should also be aware that older Foresters commonly suffered from head gasket failures, while 2011-2015 models were more susceptible to oil consumption issues. Regardless of model year, reviewing maintenance records, verifying recall completion, and arranging a pre-purchase inspection are the best ways to ensure a dependable used Forester.
Summary
When it comes to shopping in the used market, the Subaru forester is a model that's hard to go wrong with, with its excellent reliability and consistency making for a model that is sure to perform even after multiple owners. Car2Sell Hillside, NJ has an excellent selection of quality Forester models that have all had their homework done for you, so if you're looking to shop and save with a used Subaru, be sure to stop by for a stress free, simplified buying experience that's sure to leave you satisfied!